Halo 5: Guardians Review – Great Multiplayer, Messy Story

⚔️ The Most Divisive Halo

🪖 This review is part of the Halo Saga – play Master Chief’s journey in order.

No Halo splits a room like Halo 5: Guardians. Ask ten fans and you will get answers ranging from “the best multiplayer the series ever had” to “the moment the campaign lost the plot.” Both camps are right, which is what makes this entry so fascinating to review. It is a game of two halves that barely seem to belong to the same disc: a sharp, fast, brilliant competitive shooter bolted to one of the most disappointing campaigns the franchise has produced.

At Dadnology we rate Halo 5 a solid but qualified 8/10 — and we want to be upfront that this is a score weighted heavily toward its multiplayer. The campaign, on its own, would pull a lower number. But the complete package — the razor-sharp arena play, the excellent new movement, the meaty Warzone mode — adds up to a genuinely good game with a genuinely frustrating story. Manage your expectations on the plot and you will have a great time.

---

🎯 The Multiplayer: 343’s Finest Hour

Let us lead with the strength, because it is a big one. Halo 5’s arena multiplayer is the best 343 Industries ever made, and it stands with the great competitive Halo experiences. It is fast, precise, and beautifully balanced, built on a foundation of equal starts and skill expression that honored what classic Halo multiplayer was about — a welcome correction after Halo 4’s loadout experiments.

The new Spartan abilities are the engine. Every player can now sprint, clamber up ledges, thrust-dash in any direction, ground-pound from the air, and aim down a stabilized “Spartan charge.” Crucially, none of it is a loadout unlock — everyone has the same toolkit, so matches stay about skill. The result is the most mobile, kinetic competitive Halo there is, and it powered a serious esports scene for years.

Then there is Warzone: a large-scale, 24-player mode mixing PvP objectives with AI enemies and a card-based requisition system for calling in weapons and vehicles. It is chaotic, spectacular fun, and it gave the package enormous longevity. If you came to Halo 5 for multiplayer, you stayed for a very long time.

Ad

Halo 5: Guardians (Xbox Series X|S / Xbox One) (opens in a new tab)

The mainline entry not included in the Master Chief Collection. Backward compatible on Series X and on Game Pass.

---

🏃 The Sandbox: Mobility Reinvented

The Spartan abilities do not just serve multiplayer; they reinvent the campaign sandbox too. After years of grounded Halo movement, suddenly the Chief and his squad can thrust, clamber, slide, and boost, and the level design opens up vertically to match. It feels genuinely modern and fluid — arguably the best raw movement in the series before Infinite refined it further.

The campaign also introduces squad mechanics: you lead a fireteam of three AI Spartans, issuing simple commands and relying on them to revive you when you go down (which doubles as the game’s replacement for traditional difficulty scaling). It works fine, but it is also part of the problem — because the AI squad exists to paper over the single biggest thing Halo 5 took away.

---

📉 The Campaign: A Story That Misfires

Here is the disappointment. Halo 5 was marketed around a dramatic premise: Master Chief has gone rogue, and a new Spartan, Locke, is hunting him. The trailers sold a tense, personal Chief-versus-Locke confrontation — hero against hero, the legend on the run. It is a fantastic hook.

The game does not deliver it. You spend the majority of the campaign playing as Locke, not the Chief, who appears in only a handful of missions. The big confrontation the marketing promised amounts to a brief, anticlimactic scuffle. And the actual plot — pivoting around Cortana’s return and a galaxy-spanning AI uprising — fumbles its ideas, ending on a confusing setup rather than a satisfying story. It is not incompetent, and the moment-to-moment shooting is still good Halo. But as a narrative, it is the weakest mainline entry, and the gap between what was promised and what was delivered is the core of why this game is so divisive.

Ad

Xbox Series X Console (opens in a new tab)

Runs Halo 5 backward compatible and free on Game Pass — the home for the whole modern saga.

---

🛠️ Where It Sits and How to Play It

Halo 5 is the middle chapter of 343’s Reclaimer saga, following Halo 4 and leading into Halo Infinite. Notably, it is not part of Halo: The Master Chief Collection — it is sold separately, runs backward compatible on Xbox Series consoles, and is on Game Pass.

Should you play it? For the story, yes — its ending directly sets up the situation Halo Infinite opens with, so it adds context even though Infinite stands largely on its own. For the multiplayer, absolutely — it remains one of the most enjoyable competitive shooters of its generation. Just go in knowing the campaign is the package’s weak link, not its draw.

---

👨 The Dad Angle

Halo 5 is rated M with the saga’s usual clean sci-fi tone, but the dad-relevant headline is blunt: no split-screen. The game that should have been a four-controller family-night machine instead pushes you toward solo or online play, which is a real loss for couch co-op households. If shared-screen Halo is what you want, the Bungie games and Infinite serve you far better.

Where Halo 5 does deliver for dads is the after-bedtime competitive session. The arena multiplayer is fast, fair, and endlessly replayable in short bursts — a perfect fifteen-minute-match game once the house is quiet. Treat it as your online shooter rather than your couch shooter, keep your campaign expectations modest, and there is a lot of good Halo here.

---

🏟️ Warzone and the Esports Years: The Long Tail

It is worth dwelling on just how much life Halo 5’s multiplayer had, because it is the strongest argument for the score. Warzone in particular gave the game enormous longevity: a 24-player blend of team-versus-team combat, AI boss encounters, and base capture, fueled by a card-based requisition system that let you call in weapons and vehicles mid-match. It was spectacle-driven, endlessly replayable chaos — the kind of mode you could drop into for one game and lose an evening to. 343 supported it with a steady stream of free maps and updates for years, which kept the community healthy long after launch.

The competitive arena side, meanwhile, anchored a serious esports era. The Halo World Championship ran on Halo 5, with major prize pools and a genuinely thriving pro scene built on the game’s fast, fair, equal-start design. For all the campaign’s faults, the multiplayer was treated as a living product and rewarded the players who stuck with it. If you came in for the competition, Halo 5 gave you years of it.

⚖️ Halo 5 vs Halo Infinite: The 343 Showdown

The natural comparison is to 343’s next game, Halo Infinite, and the two make a fascinating pair because their strengths are almost mirror images. Halo 5 has arguably the faster, more aggressive competitive multiplayer of the two, built around the full Spartan-ability movement set — but it has the weaker campaign and the controversial no-split-screen decision. Infinite has the more grounded, classic-feeling sandbox, the brilliant grappleshot, the open ring, and the return of co-op — but it launched thin on content.

If you want the punchiest arena multiplayer and do not care about the story, Halo 5 still holds up beautifully. If you want the better single-player experience and the more Halo-feeling sandbox, Infinite is the pick. Played in order, they tell the modern Chief’s arc — Halo 5’s cliffhanger setup paying off in Infinite’s opening — so the ideal is to play both, weaknesses and all, and watch 343 visibly learn from one game to the next. It is genuinely instructive to play them as a pair: you can see the studio identify exactly what Halo 5 got wrong — the missing co-op, the Chief-light story, the trend-chasing — and methodically correct each of those mistakes in Infinite. Few back-to-back releases show a developer’s growth this clearly.

Ad

Xbox Wireless Controller – Carbon Black (opens in a new tab)

Halo 5's fast arena multiplayer rewards a comfortable pad. A spare is always worth having.

---

---

❓ FAQ: Untangling the Divisive One

Is Halo 5's campaign really that bad?

It is the most criticized mainline Halo campaign, mostly because the marketing promised a Master Chief versus Locke showdown that the game never delivers. You play as Locke for most of it, the Chief barely features, and the plot fumbles its big ideas. It is not unplayable, but it disappoints against expectations.

Is Halo 5's multiplayer good?

It is excellent, and it is the main reason to play. Halo 5 has the fastest, sharpest arena multiplayer 343 ever made, a strong competitive scene, and the large-scale Warzone mode. For many fans the multiplayer alone justifies the game.

Does Halo 5 have split-screen co-op?

No, and this was a major sore point at launch. For the first time, a mainline Halo shipped without any split-screen, online or local, breaking a long couch-co-op tradition. It is one of the game’s most-criticized omissions.

Is Halo 5 in the Master Chief Collection?

No. Halo 5: Guardians is sold separately and is not part of the Collection. It is backward compatible on Xbox Series consoles and available on Game Pass.

Should I play Halo 5 before Halo Infinite?

Yes, if you care about the story. Halo 5’s ending sets up the situation Halo Infinite opens with, so playing it first gives Infinite’s setup more context, even though Infinite is largely designed to stand on its own.

Is Halo 5 worth playing just for the campaign?

On its own, the campaign is the weakest of any mainline Halo, so it is hard to recommend buying the game for the story alone. That said, since Halo 5 is on Game Pass and backward compatible, the campaign is essentially free to play through if you are already a subscriber, and it does provide important setup for Halo Infinite. The smart approach is to treat the campaign as a bonus and the excellent multiplayer as the main attraction, rather than the other way around.