Commando (1985) Review: The Schwarzenegger Classic That Still Works

Every so often, you need to go back to a classic, and Commando is about as classic as 80s one-man-army action gets. I grew up on this stuff — Schwarzenegger, Stallone, Van Damme, the whole run of them — and revisiting Commando confirms what I already suspected: it still works, especially if you were there the first time around, and it works in a completely different way than the action movies being made today.

Ad

Commando (1985) (Blu-ray) (opens in a new tab)

The purest, most unfiltered one-man-army premise Schwarzenegger ever played, on disc.

Director Mark L. Lester and producer Joel Silver built this on a shockingly small $10 million budget, and it still topped the box office for three straight weeks. There is no elaborate plot machinery here, no twist to manage, no franchise mythology to service. It is John Matrix, a countdown, and an island full of people who made the mistake of taking his daughter. That simplicity is not a limitation; it is the entire design.

Neither of those scores tells you what actually matters here, which is that this film knows exactly what it is and never once apologizes for it.

Narrative Architecture: Twenty-Four Hours, Zero Subtlety

The plot is deliberately, almost defiantly thin. Retired Special Forces colonel John Matrix (Schwarzenegger) is living quietly with his daughter when a former subordinate, now leading a band of mercenaries, kidnaps her to force Matrix into an assassination plot. Matrix escapes his handlers almost immediately, realizes the kidnappers intend to kill his daughter regardless of whether he cooperates, and spends the rest of the film’s tight 90 minutes working through an entire private army to get her back — with a flight attendant he essentially commandeers along the way as his only ally.

There is no mystery to solve and no twist to manage. The film tells you exactly what it is in the first ten minutes and then spends the rest of its runtime delivering precisely that, escalating the body count and the one-liners in equal measure until the final island assault. For a dad who grew up with this kind of movie, that directness is the whole appeal: no padding, no franchise setup, just a man with a clear goal and the means to pursue it without hesitation.

Schwarzenegger’s screen presence carries all of this. He was not yet the polished action star of Terminator 2 or True Lies here — Commando is rawer, meaner, and more committed to pure spectacle over character nuance, and that rawness is exactly why it holds up as a specific kind of movie you cannot really make the same way anymore.

Behind the Bullets: A Different Era of Action Filmmaking

What strikes you rewatching Commando decades later is how differently action was staged and paced back then. Modern blockbusters tend toward longer runtimes, more elaborate set pieces, and CGI-driven spectacle. Commando does the opposite: 90 minutes, almost entirely practical effects, and a body count that climbs into the dozens without ever slowing down to justify itself. James Horner’s score pushes the momentum forward rather than underlining emotional beats, which fits a film that has no interest in slowing down to feel something.

Three things worth knowing if you have not revisited this one in a while:

1. Two cuts exist, and they are genuinely different films in tone. The R-rated theatrical cut leans into the one-liners; the international/director’s cut trims some of the humor for harsher, more direct violence.
2. The runtime is the point. At 90 minutes, there is no fat to trim — every scene exists to either escalate the threat or deliver a set piece.
3. The supporting cast is stronger than the plot needs it to be, with Rae Dawn Chong’s flight attendant getting more to do than the “reluctant sidekick” premise usually allows, and a young Alyssa Milano holding her own as the kidnapped daughter rather than existing purely as a plot device.

Ad

Commando (1985) (Blu-ray) (opens in a new tab)

The purest, most unfiltered one-man-army premise Schwarzenegger ever played, on disc.

Watching an 80s Classic With Fresh Eyes (or Nostalgic Ones)

There is a real difference between watching Commando cold, with no history with the genre, and watching it as someone who grew up on this exact run of films. I fall firmly into the second camp, and revisiting it confirms something worth saying plainly: this is not “so bad it’s good” the way some 80s action gets dismissed. It is a film that is extremely good at the one specific thing it set out to do, and that focus is a craft choice as much as anything.

Compare it to how a modern equivalent would handle the same premise. Today’s version would almost certainly run closer to two hours, add a conspiracy subplot, and spend real time explaining the mercenary leader’s backstory and motivations. Commando has no patience for any of that. Bennett’s grudge against Matrix gets one scene of context and then the film moves on, trusting the audience to fill in the rest and get back to the point. That trust in the audience’s patience — or rather, the total absence of any expectation that the audience needs their hand held — is exactly the quality that has mostly disappeared from big-budget action filmmaking since.

None of this is to say Commando is a hidden masterpiece of restraint. It is gloriously dumb in places, and the plot mechanics exist purely to get Matrix from one action beat to the next as efficiently as possible. But there is real craft in that efficiency, and it is worth recognizing rather than just laughing off as a relic. This is the era that produced the template every modern action star still gets measured against, whether the films admit it or not.

The Dad Verdict: Better If You Grew Up With It, Still Fun If You Didn’t

This is the honest caveat worth stating plainly: Commando lands hardest if you already have some nostalgia for this specific era of action filmmaking. The dialogue is bluntly functional, the plot logic does not withstand much scrutiny, and some of the humor has aged into pure camp. None of that is a flaw so much as a description of what the film always was.

For anyone who grew up on Schwarzenegger, Stallone, and Van Damme, revisiting Commando is a genuinely fun reminder of how lean and unpretentious this genre used to be before it needed a cinematic universe to justify itself. Our full ranking of the classic action era puts Commando alongside Die Hard, Predator, and Terminator 2 as one of the ten essential rewatches — and if you want to see how the genre evolved from here, that same list also points toward the modern equivalents worth knowing.

Prefer to catch classics on a streaming trial before committing to the disc? Prime Video’s 30-day free trial is worth checking — 80s catalogs rotate in and out constantly.

Is Commando worth watching?

Yes, especially if you grew up with 80s action movies or already love Schwarzenegger, Stallone, or Van Damme in this era. It is lean, unapologetic, and still delivers. A strong 4 out of 5.

Where can I watch Commando?

Commando is available to buy or rent digitally and on Blu-ray. It also rotates through streaming platforms’ catalogs periodically.

Who directed Commando?

Mark L. Lester directed Commando, from a screenplay by Jeph Loeb, Matthew Weisman, and Steven E. de Souza. Joel Silver produced.

Is Commando the same as the theatrical cut everyone remembers?

There are two versions: the R-rated theatrical cut and a more violent international/director’s cut, which trims some of the one-liners in favor of harsher action. Most home releases include both.

Is Commando suitable for kids?

It is rated R, though by today’s standards its violence sits closer to a hard PG-13. It is a fine introduction to 80s action for older teens who already know this is a different, more stylized kind of movie than what gets made now.