The Rings of Power Season 1 Review: Sauron Revealed
The Rings of Power Season 1 is a lavish Second-Age opener that builds to a brilliant Sauron reveal. A strong 8/10 if you set expectations right.
This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no extra cost to you.
Introduction
🔥 This review is part of The Rings of Power Series – Amazon’s Second-Age epic, reviewed season by season.
Stepping into Middle-earth carries a particular pressure, and The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power walked in under the heaviest expectations any new show could face. You arrive braced for disappointment — and then have to do the honest work of judging it on its own terms rather than against a perfect film trilogy. Do that, and Season 1 is a genuine, if patient, success. Our verdict: a strong 8.
AdThe Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power (Seasons 1 & 2) (opens in a new tab)
Stream both seasons of the Second-Age epic on Prime Video — the complete story so far.
This is the most expensive television ever made, and every dollar is on screen. But the real reason it earns its 8 isn’t the budget — it’s the season-long mystery box that pays off brilliantly in the finale. For the Dadnology community, this is an 8/10: high-end, world-class production with a story that’s smarter than its early, slow episodes let on.
The pitch is irresistible: the forging of the Rings, the rise of Sauron, and the fall of Númenor — the deep history the films only ever hinted at.
Narrative Architecture: A Slow Build to a Sharp Reveal
The Second Age is unfamiliar ground even for many fans, and the show takes its time laying it out. Multiple threads run in parallel: Galadriel’s obsessive hunt for a returning evil; the Harfoots and a mysterious stranger fallen from the sky; the forging partnership of Elrond and the dwarf-prince Durin; and the simmering Southlands, where a hidden enemy is about to turn into Mordor.
It’s a lot, and the early episodes are deliberate to a fault — beautiful, but slow. The reward is the back half, when the threads start to pull tight and the mystery the season has been quietly building snaps into focus.
For dads, there’s a satisfying thematic spine here about how evil rarely arrives as an army — it arrives as a friend, a good idea, a helping hand. The show is patient enough to make that point land, even if it asks for patience in return.
| Thread | Galadriel | The Southlands |
|---|---|---|
| Drive | Hunting a returning evil | Ordinary folk under a gathering shadow |
| Key Figure | Halbrand, a charming stranger | Adar and the orcs |
| Tone | Restless, militant | Slow-burn dread |
| Payoff | The Sauron reveal | The birth of Mordor |
| Strength | Morfydd Clark's intensity | Genuine sense of looming doom |
The two strongest threads converge on the same revelation — and it’s a good one.
The Reveal: Sauron Hiding in Plain Sight
The cleverest thing Season 1 does is hide its villain for eight episodes. We meet Halbrand as a shipwrecked survivor Galadriel pulls from the open ocean — a man claiming to be an ordinary human from the Southlands whose home the orcs destroyed. All season, we read that meeting as fate, a miraculous coincidence. Galadriel is the one who drags him back into the story, pushes him to claim a kingship, and brings him to the Elves at Eregion.
Then the finale pulls the rug. When Galadriel checks the royal bloodline of the Southlands, she finds the line of kings died out a thousand years ago. Halbrand is no king. Halbrand is Sauron — and the “chance” encounter on the endless ocean was the Dark Lord patiently engineering his way back to power. It’s a genuinely great twist that re-frames the entire season in a single cold moment, and it’s the strongest argument for the show’s deliberate build.
The Craft, and the Caveats
Visually, the show is staggering. Númenor, the forges of Eregion, the eruption that creates Mount Doom — it’s all rendered with feature-film budget and care, and it reads as one of the best-looking things on television.
The honest caveats are real, though, and worth naming:
- Pace: The early episodes are slow, and some viewers will bounce off before the payoff arrives.
- Logic holes: A few compressed timelines and convenient distances ask you to look the other way. If that breaks a show for you, fair warning.
- Mystery-box fatigue: Some plotlines (the Stranger’s identity) lean a little hard on withholding information for its own sake.
LEGO Icons The Lord of the Rings: Sauron's Helmet (11373) (opens in a new tab)
The Dark Lord's helm in display form — a fitting companion to the season's big reveal.
None of it sinks the season — but it’s why we land on a confident 8 rather than a 9.
The Format Benchmark: A Streaming Showcase
For the home-cinema dad, Season 1 is a fantastic demo for a good TV and sound setup — provided you give it room to breathe.
- Reference visuals: The production design is so detailed it rewards the best picture quality you can stream.
- Sound and score: Bear McCreary’s music is a highlight; the finale’s eruption is a genuine subwoofer moment.
- Dad Alert: This is a “pay attention” show, not a second-screen one. Save it for after the kids are down, when you can actually follow the threads — the back-half payoff depends on it.
LEGO Icons The Lord of the Rings: Barad-dûr (10333) (opens in a new tab)
Sauron's tower with a light-brick Eye — the perfect shelf piece for a season built around his hidden return.
The Online Storm, and Why to Ignore It
No show in recent memory arrived into a more toxic atmosphere than The Rings of Power. Before a single frame aired, it was caught in a culture-war crossfire — review-bombed, dogpiled, and argued over by people who, in many cases, clearly hadn’t watched it. That noise made it genuinely hard to judge the thing on its own merits, and it’s worth saying plainly: most of the loudest complaints had little to do with the actual quality of the television on screen. If you’ve been put off by the discourse, our advice is to mute it entirely and watch the show cold.
Do that, and what you’ll find is a flawed but frequently gorgeous fantasy drama that takes real swings. Is it Tolkien-faithful in every particular? No — it’s adapting fragments and appendices into a full narrative, and that means invention, compression, and the occasional bold reinterpretation. But it’s made with obvious love for the world, and its best episodes capture something the films sometimes lacked: the sense of Middle-earth as a vast, ancient place with histories we’ve only ever glimpsed in passing. Judged as television rather than as a referendum, Season 1 is a confident, good-looking debut.
Watching It as a Tolkien Fan
For the dad who grew up on the books and films, the season offers a specific pleasure: seeing the deep backstory dramatised at last. Names you only ever read in the appendices — Númenor, Celebrimbor, the forging of the Rings — become places and people and events. There’s a genuine thrill in watching the island kingdom of Númenor at its height, knowing the tragedy that’s coming, or in seeing the first seeds of Mordor planted in the Southlands. The show trusts you to feel the weight of dramatic irony, and for longtime fans, that pays off handsomely.
It does ask for patience, and it asks you to meet it halfway on a few liberties. But there’s a real warmth to its world-building, and the central mystery rewards your investment with one of the best villain reveals in recent television. If you can set aside the impossible standard of “as good as the films” and the online noise around it, Season 1 is a rich, rewarding way back into Middle-earth — and a foundation the show builds on impressively from here.
Pros
- The most lavish, detailed production on television — every dollar is on screen
- A genuinely brilliant season-long mystery that pays off in the Sauron reveal
- Morfydd Clark's Galadriel and the Elrond-Durin friendship are standouts
- Bear McCreary's score gives the Second Age its own distinct sound
Cons
- Deliberately slow early episodes test first-time viewers' patience
- A handful of logic holes and compressed timelines require forgiveness
- Some mystery-box plotting withholds information a little too long
- It's setup-heavy — the show is clearly building toward bigger things
Conclusion: A Patient Opener That Earns Its Twist
The Rings of Power Season 1 is a high-quality, beautifully made introduction to the Second Age that rewards patience with one of the best villain reveals in recent television. Set your expectations against “great fantasy TV” rather than “the perfect film trilogy,” forgive a couple of stumbles, and it’s a real success.
It’s a season that gets better the more of it you’ve seen — and that builds a foundation the second season is poised to capitalise on.
The Final Word: A strong, patient 8/10. Stick with the slow start; the Sauron reveal makes it worth it.
Is The Rings of Power Season 1 worth watching?
Who is Halbrand in The Rings of Power?
Do I need to read Tolkien to follow The Rings of Power?
Is The Rings of Power Season 1 suitable for kids?
Why is The Rings of Power so expensive?
Disclaimer: This review and its visuals were created with the help of AI. Some links may be affiliate links – we may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no extra cost to you.
You might also like
The Rings of Power Season 2 Review: Sauron Unleashed
Sauron unleashed, and a show learning what it's great at. The first half is solid 8 territory; the final three episodes — and the one-take Battle of Eregion — are a clear 9. A strong 8/10 overall.
The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey Review - An Honest 6/10
A pleasant, overlong return to Middle-earth that buckles under the weight of what came before. Martin Freeman is perfect and Riddles in the Dark is sublime, but the padding shows. An honest 6/10.
The Battle of the Five Armies Review: A 6/10 Finale
A breathless, battle-heavy finale that closes the trilogy more with exhaustion than triumph. Smaug's opening and Thorin's downfall are the highlights. An honest 6/10.