Birds of Prey (2020) Review: Harley Quinn Finally Gets Her Film

Birds of Prey opens with Harley Quinn narrating her own backstory in an animated sequence while simultaneously explaining, with considerable relish, that she has just broken up with the Joker and that this means she is no longer protected by his reputation. Everyone in Gotham who has ever had a reason to want her dead now has an open season. It is an excellent premise for an R-rated action film, and director Cathy Yan executes it with the kind of confident, specific visual style that the DCEU had been desperately needing more of.

Ad

Birds of Prey (4K Ultra HD + Blu-ray) (opens in a new tab)

The extended R-rated cut is the correct version. The color grading pops significantly in 4K HDR.

Margot Robbie’s Harley Quinn, finally freed from the Suicide Squad ensemble and given a proper film of her own, is a revelation. She was great in 2016 — remarkable, even, against the film’s limitations. But here, with room to breathe and a script that understands her as a fully-formed character rather than a walking aesthetic, she’s extraordinary. Harley is funny and dangerous and occasionally deeply vulnerable in ways the Suicide Squad treatment never allowed. There’s a scene early in the film in which she eats a breakfast sandwich alone in the diner where she and the Joker had their first date, in the neighborhood she can’t go back to, and it is surprisingly moving. Robbie plays the loneliness of someone who structured their entire identity around a relationship and is now working out who they are without it.

Ewan McGregor’s Roman Sionis / Black Mask is the film’s most unhinged element, which is saying something in a film anchored by Harley Quinn. He’s a Gotham crime boss with a pathological vanity, a casual relationship with extreme violence, and the specific kind of entitled male rage that makes him dangerous in ways the film deploys with considerable satirical sharpness. McGregor appears to be having the time of his life — flamboyant, cruel, genuinely funny in his absurdity, and consistently terrifying when the film decides to make him so. It’s a committed performance and one of the DCEU’s more memorably vivid villains.

Narrative Architecture: Emancipation as Genre

The film’s title tells you its thesis: this is a story about Harley Quinn’s emancipation. Not from the Joker specifically — the film dispatches that story with admirable efficiency — but from the identity she constructed around him. The Fantabulous Emancipation of One Harley Quinn is a liberation narrative dressed as an action comedy, and Cathy Yan is smart enough to make the liberation feel genuinely earned.

The central MacGuffin — a diamond containing a stolen fortune, swallowed by a teenage pickpocket named Cassandra Cain — is less important than the ensemble it assembles around it. Black Canary (Jurnee Smollett) is a nightclub singer with an extraordinary power she hasn’t allowed herself to use. Huntress (Mary Elizabeth Winstead) is a trained assassin pursuing a specific revenge agenda with absolutely no social skills. Renee Montoya (Rosie Perez) is a Gotham detective who has spent her career watching men take credit for her work. Each of these women has a different relationship with powerlessness and each finds a version of liberation through the film’s events. Yan weaves these parallel threads with real structural confidence.

The film’s non-linear structure — Harley narrates events in the order she remembers them, which is not chronological — is initially disorienting and ultimately exactly right. It mirrors Harley’s chaotic internal logic. The moment in which she pauses the narrative to go back and show you how Roman Sionis actually discovered who she is — because she realizes she left it out earlier — is a specific kind of meta-humor that the film earns through commitment.

The Action Choreography: This Is How You Do It

Ad

Harley Quinn Birds of Prey DC Multiverse Figure (opens in a new tab)

The Birds of Prey costume design — bright, chaotic, absolutely Harley — translates beautifully to the collectible format.

Chad Stahelski’s team (John Wick) consulted on the choreography, and it shows. The action in Birds of Prey is among the best in the superhero genre — inventive, practical where possible, and designed around Harley’s specific weapon set (a mallet, roller skates, a hyenas-and-glitter aesthetic) rather than the generic “superhero hits things” template.

The Gotham Police Department evidence lockup sequence, which arrives about forty minutes before the end, is the film’s masterpiece. Harley, needing to fight through a building full of armed police while keeping Cassandra safe and unable to use lethal force, solves the problem with equipment she finds in the property room: confetti cannons, bright paint, a beanbag shotgun, skates. It is choreographed with obvious delight, shot with clarity that most action films cannot manage, and runs for a sustained period without a cut to safety. It’s the sequence that established Birds of Prey as a genre achievement rather than just a good film.

Daniel Pemberton’s score contributes significantly — it’s deliberately retro, leaning on analogue synths and drum machine textures that give the film a specific 1980s-feminist-cinema energy that matches Yan’s visual references (the film openly acknowledges its debt to 9 to 5 and similar genre touchstones).

Ad

Birds of Prey (Blu-ray) (opens in a new tab)

Great in HD. One of the most visually stylish DCEU films and it shows even at standard definition.

Is Birds of Prey rated R?

Yes — strong violence and language throughout, some drug content. It is not a family film. 16+ is the right guidance. This is intentional: Yan wanted to make an adult-oriented DC film that didn’t soften its edges.

Do I need to see Suicide Squad (2016) first?

It helps for the Joker-Harley backstory context, but the film explicitly recaps it in its opening and is designed to work as a standalone. Harley moving on from Joker is the premise, not the mystery.

Who directed Birds of Prey?

Cathy Yan, making her the first woman of color to direct a major superhero film. She brought a bold visual style and genuine comedic intelligence that gave the film a distinctive personality.

Why did Birds of Prey underperform at the box office?

Multiple factors: February release, R rating, a title change from Harley Quinn: Birds of Prey (which caused some marketplace confusion), and an adult tone that didn’t align with the franchise’s typical family audience. It has since built a substantial cult following.

What is the egg sandwich scene about?

It is the best scene in the film and possibly the most relatable moment in superhero cinema: Harley Quinn, newly single and broke, goes back to the diner where she and the Joker had their first date and orders the breakfast sandwich that was always hers, even when everything else was his. It is a scene about reclaiming small joys after a big loss, and Margot Robbie plays it perfectly.