Toy Story 2 (1999) Review: The Sequel That Hits Harder Than the Original

Here is the thing about Toy Story 2 (1999) that nobody tells you before you sit down to watch it with your children: you think you are prepared. You saw the original, you know the rules, you have your snacks. Then four minutes into Jessie’s backstory you realize you are not prepared at all, and you spend the rest of the film trying to compose yourself before the school run.

Pixar’s second feature was never supposed to be a theatrical film. The studio originally developed it as a direct-to-video sequel — the kind of lower-budget franchise extension that Disney was notorious for in the late 1990s. Somewhere in production, the creative team recognized they had the bones of something much better. They rebuilt the film from scratch, extended the scope, and delivered a sequel that not only matched the original but added a dimension that no first film could have had.

Ad

Toy Story 2 (4K Ultra HD + Blu-ray) (opens in a new tab)

The 4K restoration reveals texture details in Jessie's hat and Woody's stitching that were invisible in previous home releases. Worth the upgrade for the 'When She Loved Me' sequence alone.

The gamble paid off to the tune of $497 million worldwide. More importantly, it paid off in terms of what Toy Story 2 actually does to the people who watch it. Which is to say: it locates the precise frequency at which adults process grief about impermanence and plays it very loudly for four minutes in the middle of an otherwise cheerful animated film about a cowboy’s kidnapping.

For the record: Toy Story 2 is a better film for adults than the original. This is not a popular take, but it is the correct one. The first film is a more perfect object — tighter, more revolutionary, a single sustained argument for what computer animation could do. The sequel is a richer experience. It has more to say and it says it more quietly, which is how the best things get said.

Woody’s Crisis: The Museum Piece vs The Beloved Toy

The inciting event of Toy Story 2 is not the kidnapping itself — it is the moment immediately before it. Woody’s arm tears during play with Andy. He is placed on the shelf rather than packed for Cowboy Camp. The shelf, in this universe, is the beginning of the end. A toy on the shelf is a toy whose working life is over.

Woody is subsequently stolen by Al McWhiggin, a toy collector, and taken to be prepared for sale to a museum in Japan as part of the complete Woody’s Roundup set alongside Jessie, Bullseye, and the Prospector. The offer Al and the Prospector present to Woody is coherent and seductive: in a museum, Woody will be loved forever, behind glass, by millions of people. With Andy, he will be loved for a few more years, then discarded like every other toy that outlasted its owner’s childhood.

This is, if you squint, exactly the choice facing anyone who has built something good and must decide between the comfortable certainty of preservation and the messy, finite risk of being actually used. A career decision. A relationship decision. The kind of decision that only seems clear in retrospect. Pixar put it in a film about toys in 1999 and teenagers who saw it at the time are still thinking about it.

The counterargument — which Buzz makes and which the film endorses — is that being truly loved, even for a finite time, by one person who actually needs you is worth more than being perfectly preserved for abstract admiration. As a dad, you know which side of that argument you are on.

Ad

Jessie the Cowgirl Doll (opens in a new tab)

The classic Jessie doll with her signature yodel button. Your kid will want one after the film. You will want one after 'When She Loved Me'. Both are valid.

When She Loved Me: The Four Minutes That Wreck Everything

There is a category of film sequence that functions as a precision instrument for a specific kind of adult emotion. The kind that does not have a name in daily life but is instantly recognizable when you encounter it unexpectedly in a darkened cinema or a quiet living room. Jessie’s backstory is that sequence.

Four minutes. Sarah McLachlan’s “When She Loved Me” playing over a wordless montage of a girl — Emily — growing up. The sequence shows Jessie and Emily inseparable in childhood: tea parties, backyard adventures, a girl for whom this toy is the whole world. Then Emily grows up. A teenager arrives who has no time for Jessie. The toy ends up in a donation box at the side of the road.

The filmmaking is extraordinary in its restraint. Director Lee Unkrich shoots the older Emily in fragments — a pair of jeans, a teenage bedroom wall — never showing her face fully, because the film understands that showing her full face would make her a villain. She is not a villain. She simply grew up. The horror of the sequence is not betrayal but inevitability. The horror is that nobody is to blame.

For any parent who has looked at their child and felt that specific complicated love — enormous and temporary all at once — this sequence does not merely affect you. It finds you. Watch it at 8 years old and it is a sad song about a toy. Watch it at 38 with your child asleep on your shoulder and it is something else entirely.

Stinky Pete and the Shape of Resentment

The Prospector — Stinky Pete — is the most interesting villain in the Toy Story series. He has never been opened. Still in his box, never played with, never loved by a child. When Woody decides to return to Andy, Stinky Pete reveals what decades of unlived life produces: not sadness, but rage. The rage of someone who has convinced themselves that the thing they were denied was not worth wanting.

Kelsey Grammer’s performance makes the villain frightening rather than merely pathetic. The shift from avuncular to threatening is fast, quiet, and effective — exactly how real resentment works, which is to say without warning. The scene in the baggage compartment where Stinky Pete corners Woody and Jessie is legitimately tense and marks the second time in the series (after Sid) where Pixar trusted a sequence to be properly scary rather than safely exciting.

The 6+ guidance for Part 2 accounts primarily for Stinky Pete’s third-act reveal and the emotional weight of Jessie’s backstory, which younger children do not have the scaffolding to process without support.

The Airport Finale: Earned Spectacle

The final sequence of Toy Story 2 — the chase through an airport, Woody and Jessie escaping in the luggage compartment, Bullseye galloping across the tarmac — is the kind of set piece that only works because the film spent 80 minutes earning it. You care about Jessie being left behind because you know her story. You care about Bullseye because Woody built a relationship with him in Al’s apartment. Even the resolution of whether Woody should return to Andy has weight because the film spent its middle act arguing the opposing case honestly.

Ad

Toy Story 2 (Blu-ray) (opens in a new tab)

The reliable physical release. Sharp, complete, and the bonus materials include early development footage that shows how close this film came to being a direct-to-video release.

The arrival back home, with Jessie joining Andy’s room and Bullseye establishing his place in the group, is played with the perfect register: warmly and briefly, without milking it. The coda — Woody and Buzz watching the stars, Woody acknowledging that Andy will one day grow up — is the only moment in the film that looks ahead to Part 3, and it is devastating in retrospect because we know what is coming.

Is Toy Story 2 better than the original?

Toy Story 2 is in genuine contention for the title. The original is more innovative and more formally perfect. The sequel is emotionally richer and has more to say. Depending on whether you weight technical achievement or emotional depth, either film can win the argument. Watch them back to back and make your own call.

What is the 'When She Loved Me' sequence?

It is a four-minute wordless montage showing Jessie’s history with her owner Emily: childhood inseparability followed by a teenager who no longer has time for her, ending in donation. Scored by Sarah McLachlan and directed with devastating restraint. It will make you think about your childhood toys. It will also make you look at your child and feel things you do not have words for.

Is Toy Story 2 suitable for young children?

We recommend 6 and up. The emotional weight of Jessie’s backstory is overwhelming for very young children who lack the vocabulary for what they are feeling. Stinky Pete’s threatening third-act reveal is also sharper than most family films manage. Manageable for most children over 6, but have the conversation beforehand.

Who are the new characters in Toy Story 2?

Jessie the cowgirl, Bullseye the horse, and Stinky Pete the Prospector are the main additions, all part of the fictional Woody’s Roundup toy line from a 1950s television show. Zurg also makes his first appearance as the in-universe villain of Buzz’s mythology. Kelsey Grammer voices Stinky Pete; Joan Cusack voices Jessie.